How not to celebrate your restaurant's revenue

We often make the mistake of judging money only by its volume, focusing solely on maximising revenue without paying enough attention to what it actually cost us.
If you have already considered how not to open a restaurant, and we recommend reading that article if you have not, but still want to take the plunge, I will now discuss how not to choose your business model. A common misconception is that we can set up somewhere and, at worst, copy what everyone else does. Thoughtless imitation is dangerous. The basic requirement is to consider everything and define our restaurant's operating principles ourselves.
Different factors affect every hospitality business's return on investment. Staff numbers, overheads, rent and the list goes on. Yet some models and promotions cannot make economic sense unless everything arriving at the restaurant is free.
Money in hospitality
What subject could be more unavoidable than money? Hospitality rests on a constant conflict: guests want plenty for little money, while operators would prefer to offer less at a higher price.
The key to a successful restaurant is convincing guests that what they pay is reasonable and that the experience was worth every forint. There are many ways to do this. Our examples look at how to avoid spending too much on proving it.
We know the familiar maths for permanent menu items. Calculate what they cost you, multiply by three, preferably four, and perhaps something remains at the end of the month. If your restaurant is good, a few tables at lunchtime and especially in the evening make opening worthwhile. But what about the time between? What happens when most potential guests are at work until 3 pm? Let's offer a lunch menu, they said. It will be great for us. But is it worthwhile for you?
As one kind commenter put it, "the suicidal set-menu operator" also deserves a few lines. That fits our subject perfectly, since we are examining revenue and profit.
I have divided hospitality businesses into two groups by return on investment. We will compare à la carte and set-menu restaurants in simplified terms, strictly relative to each other, considering financial advantages and disadvantages.
À la carte restaurants
The first is the classic à la carte restaurant, where guests choose from a menu apart from a few specials or events. In terms of operating mechanics, this also includes pizzerias and burger restaurants.
In terms of returns:
- This is the clearest model. If everyone follows the calculations and minimises kitchen waste, the numbers should work. This saves money.
- Guests choose what they want, then the kitchen prepares it almost from scratch as quickly as possible. No food is prepared unnecessarily. This saves money.
- You need a larger kitchen team because different people must cook different components to have them ready simultaneously. This is a cost.
- We sometimes battle fiercely with suppliers, seek the best value, revisit alternatives and negotiate hard, but cannot expect miracles. Purchase prices will be similar everywhere. This is a cost.
- If the system works well, we pay only for ingredients we subsequently sell. This saves money.
Buffet and set-menu restaurants
The other model is the set-menu or buffet business, where we aim to sell a prepared quantity of food for the best possible return. This includes all-you-can-eat restaurants, canteens beneath office buildings and food stalls in markets.
In terms of returns here:
- Things are more complicated because we serve more people at lower prices, with a different speed of service. Calculations change continuously and figures are harder to track. This is a cost.
- Kitchen preparation may be simpler than à la carte because dishes do not need to be made almost from scratch in minutes. Advance preparation is easier, so fewer people can work more efficiently. This saves money.
- There are lots of leftovers! The most expensive food is what we have already prepared, investing ingredients and labour, only to throw it away. This is a cost.
- Negotiating with suppliers is worthwhile. Bulk-order discounts can leave a noticeable amount in your pocket at month-end. Discounted products arrive regularly, sometimes with shorter shelf lives, but incorporating them into the next day's menu benefits us again. This saves money.
- Quality! Holding food warm and serving quickly makes it harder to produce an outstanding plate. A point in favour of à la carte.
To borrow a classic joke, we miscounted, gentlemen, because there is a third type. In fact, these businesses' special characteristics inspired this article:
A mixed restaurant model
These are restaurants operating a mixed system. They rarely excel at both styles, but I will give an example shortly, because I was fortunate to work at an outstanding member of this rare group.
By mixed systems, I mean restaurants offering a set lunch menu and then, say, only à la carte service from 3 pm. This also includes places advertising all-you-can-eat dining only on the last day of the week. In the latter case, make no mistake: they serve the week's leftovers, and we are essentially smiling as we help ourselves from the slop barrel. But that is a subject for another time.
Set lunch menus have become hugely fashionable. Their original purpose is to give working people a small, inexpensive hot meal without waiting, enough to keep starvation away before they return to work and dream of dinner at home. You could call it consideration or kindness from the restaurant, because it certainly generates no profit, although it does have advantages.
The menu can change daily, and restaurants reserve the right to alter it even after advertising. This creates an opportunity to use accumulated or stranded ingredients that would otherwise often fill the bin. This does not automatically mean poor quality. Notice how menus at daily lunch venues build on one another. Monday's pork stew can become Bakony-style ragout on Tuesday and pork ragout soup on Wednesday. Without this thinking, a restaurant cannot generate even minimal profit, and set-menu service becomes a hobby. Economic reasons make this approach understandable, but where the restaurant draws the line is ethically important.
Now for the real positives. There is a reason set lunches have become so widespread.
- Filling the restaurant at noon with an inexpensive offer is excellent marketing. Crowds attract crowds here too, and à la carte guests may enter when they see a busy restaurant at lunchtime.
- Money. Above a certain number of portions sold, a very large number, you may cover a month's electricity bill.
- Employees need work. Even if the operator's pockets do not fill up, staff can earn at least part of their wages instead of spending half their ten-hour shift on their phones.
There are also restaurants with excellent systems that deliver real value and quality. As promised, here is a specific example. Sadly, I can name Flaska because it no longer operates, although it did not close for financial reasons.
The system had very simple principles: lunch offers only at midday and à la carte only in the evening. From Monday to Friday, lunch guests could choose from 2 soups, 5 main courses and 1 dessert, while the evening menu could change seasonally. This served walk-in guests and workers who hurried out from the office each day and wanted a different main course throughout the week. The lunch offer exceeded the average Budapest restaurant's à la carte quality. Its price was also closer to à la carte than most set menus, but the real strengths were speed and portion size. Because the kitchen had to focus on only these 8 items, it could produce them quickly and to a high standard. Portions only needed to be large enough to satisfy an adult. With enough persistence, a sustainable customer base develops, offering a real restaurant atmosphere through a menu designed, excuse the expression, for "workers". Eating a set lunch in elegant surroundings becomes prestigious while retaining the actual advantages of a lunch menu: portion size and speed.
Then, after a quick kitchen changeover and 1–2 hours' rest, the classic evening menu begins, with quality raised another level.
If our chosen concept finds the right customers, financial security comes within reach. But we always need more guests, so we start advertising promotions to attract them. Sometimes these go so badly wrong that they take money out of our pockets instead of adding revenue. The next mathematical puzzle is promotions.
Promotions in hospitality
The two main considerations when planning a promotion:
1.) Does it make financial sense?
Can gifts and discounts attract enough people to generate additional revenue? It is easy to calculate that charging 10% less while attracting 10% more guests still does not pay.
For simplicity, assume average daily revenue of HUF 90,000. Two-thirds covers costs, leaving HUF 30,000 profit. Revenue divided by 3. If a 10% discount attracts an extra HUF 9,000, the HUF 99,000 revenue becomes HUF 89,100 after the discount. Dividing that by 3 gives HUF 29,700 profit. We have worked more for less.
2.) Does it make marketing sense?
There is nothing wrong with the financial example if it helps people discover us. If it builds a regular customer base, the sacrifice is worthwhile. Only 1% of promotional guests need to return on days without discounts for us to make progress.
As marketing became more professional, announcing some kind of promotion became part of everyday hospitality. We know ads such as "share this advertisement and enter a prize draw", "it's Wednesday, so drinks are half price" or "spend over X and get a free dessert". But there are much more extreme and much sillier approaches. Here is what to avoid:
The more extreme:
I encountered a promotion offering a car in a draw among people who shared a post. Unsurprisingly, it became a scandal. Few noticed the offer from an obscure little venue, so in retaliation they awarded the car to nobody. The parties may still be in court. This was not a well-considered move.
Giving everything away to everyone at an event may also sound appealing, but usually only the word "free" attracts people, and they never return, however much they enjoyed the promotion. A completely free promotion never pays off. The service devalues itself so much that it loses its worth and the whole exercise backfires.
The sillier:
Countless businesses still look at nearby prices and set their own accordingly. I am not suggesting you ignore competitors, but offering the same dishes for a few forints less, please, we can be more creative. Running a promotion simply to be cheaper than the neighbour, with essentially the same offering, is foolish. If you want a lower price bracket than competitors, use cheaper ingredients or different preparation methods. But offer distinctive dishes based on your own recipes. They can be cheaper and more special at the same time, which guests see as a positive.
The result
I have revealed no great secret, but let us accept the timeless truth that anything can be done well or badly. Mixed-model restaurants face the greatest difficulty but also address the largest audience.
Everyone must decide their priorities and how they want to earn money. List the advantages and disadvantages, carefully assess your venue's characteristics and opportunities, develop a clear picture of potential customers and choose a direction accordingly. Whether running a set-menu or à la carte restaurant, the operator who adapts best will always be the most profitable.
Written by Tamás Kállay
Last updated:
Do you need professional software?
Try it without commitment and request our free demo.
- Simple to use and quick to learn,
- Professional solutions for every size,
- Saves time and energy for you and your team.